Retired Brick Sets
LEGO 40597 Scary Pirate Island

40597Scary Pirate Island

  • 2023released
  • 214pieces
  • 1minifigures
  • Creatortheme
Typical new & sealed £23.71 from £17.70 · 11.1p/piece
Typical used & complete – from – · too few listings
Best trusted deal right now£17.70 New & sealed · · 25% below typical View on eBay →
Updated 4h ago · 45 listings found

Price history

eBay UK · median Buy It Now asking price

We started tracking this set on 18 Oct 2026. The chart fills in as we record prices each day.

45 listings

  1. Lego Creator Set 40597 Scary Pirate Island - NEW & SEALED
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions ⏱ 6d 15h · 0 bids
    forbiddenfinds_co · 100% · 280 feedback
    £14.18 incl. £3.38 postage 6.6p/piece Current bid
  2. LEGO Creator Scary Pirate Island 40597
    UK Used · not stated ⏱ 5d 12h · 0 bids
    1918carole · 100% · 494 feedback
    £15.34 incl. £2.94 postage 7.2p/piece Current bid
  3. LEGO Creator 40597 (New, Sealed) Excellent Condition
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    phoenixvulture · 100% · 122 feedback
    £17.70 incl. £2.62 postage 8.3p/piece 25% below typical
  4. LEGO 40597 Creator Scary Pirate Island Set
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    5r4ch_84 · 100% · 3 feedback · ⚠ check carefully
    £18.41 incl. £2.26 postage 8.6p/piece 22% below typical
  5. Lego Set 40597 - Scary Pirate Island
    UK Used · not stated
    sima77 · 100% · 693 feedback
    £18.41 incl. £2.26 postage 8.6p/piece Not enough data
  6. Lego Creator set 40597 - Scary Pirate Island - BNIB.
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    pama-mari · 100% · 1,534 feedback
    £18.76 incl. £2.62 postage 8.8p/piece 21% below typical
  7. LEGO Creator 40597 Scary Pirate Island Building Set Vip Insiders GWP
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    bonner1982 · 100% · 183 feedback
    £18.77 incl. £2.62 postage 8.8p/piece 21% below typical
  8. LEGO 40597 Scary Pirate Island * Brand New And Sealed
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    sp_directglobal_sales · 100% · 9,916 feedback
    £19.00 incl. £4.50 postage 8.9p/piece 20% below typical
  9. LEGO Creator Scary Pirate Island (40597) - Brand New & Sealed (BNIB)
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    ye_olde_brickworks · 100% · 9 feedback · ⚠ check carefully
    £19.47 incl. £2.26 postage 9.1p/piece 18% below typical
  10. LEGO 40597 Scary Pirate Island - New Sealed Box
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    sector77bricks · 100% · 85 feedback
    £19.67 incl. £2.62 postage 9.2p/piece 17% below typical
  11. Lego Creator: Scary Pirate Island (40597) Brand New, Free Postage
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    bartatbricks · 100% · 919 feedback
    £19.99 free postage 9.3p/piece 16% below typical
  12. LEGO Creator 40597 Scary Pirate Island New Sealed w/ Pirate Minifigure & Bat
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    applezippoandmetronome · 100% · 228 feedback
    £20.62 incl. £2.62 postage 9.6p/piece 13% below typical
  13. Lego Creator Set 40597 Scary Pirate Island Promotion Exclusive - NEW & SEALED
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    tcgrayquaza · 100% · 11 feedback
    £20.91 incl. £2.62 postage 9.8p/piece 12% below typical
  14. LEGO CREATOR promotional set 40597 | Scary Pirate Island | Brand New & Sealed
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    mrsscofe · 100% · 170 feedback
    £21.50 free postage 10.0p/piece 9% below typical
  15. LEGO Creator 40597 Scary Pirate Island New Sealed w/ Pirate Minifigure & Bat
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    ka3045 · 88.9% · 48 feedback · ⚠ check carefully
    £21.62 incl. £2.26 postage 10.1p/piece 9% below typical
  16. LEGO Creator: Scary Pirate Island (40597) GWP New With All Four Seals Intact
    UK Used · not stated
    malgogocl0 · 100% · 167 feedback
    £21.98 incl. £2.62 postage 10.3p/piece Not enough data
  17. Lego Creator 40597 Brand New And Sealed
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    gorillatokens · 100% · 2,069 feedback
    £21.98 incl. £2.62 postage 10.3p/piece 7% below typical
  18. Lego Creator: Scary Pirate Island (40597). Brand New & Sealed. Free UK Delivery.
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    simonharrison1234 · 98.6% · 790 feedback
    £22.25 incl. £2.26 postage 10.4p/piece 6% below typical
  19. New Sealed lego Creator Scary Pirate Island 40597
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    enjoymystuffuk · 100% · 563 feedback
    £22.26 incl. £2.26 postage 10.4p/piece 6% below typical
  20. Lego GWP 40597 Scary Pirate (Cove) Island - Brand New And Sealed
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    m155any · 100% · 792 feedback
    £22.36 incl. £3.00 postage 10.4p/piece 6% below typical
  21. LEGO Creator Scary Pirate Island 40597 Brand New Sealed
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    silentninja85 · 100% · 344 feedback
    £22.68 incl. £2.26 postage 10.6p/piece About typical
  22. Lego Creator Set 40597 Scary Pirate Island - NEW & SEALED
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    az5893 · 98.9% · 545 feedback
    £22.69 incl. £2.26 postage 10.6p/piece About typical
  23. LEGO Creator Scary Pirate Island (40597) - Brand New & Sealed (BNIB)
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    jtsmith000 · 100% · 971 feedback
    £22.69 incl. £6.10 postage 10.6p/piece About typical
  24. Lego 40597 Scary Pirate Island Brand New & Sealed Retired Set
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    andyp9553 · 100% · 593 feedback
    £23.64 incl. £3.65 postage 11.0p/piece About typical
  25. NEW LEGO 40597 LEGO Creator Scary Pirate Island Halloween Gift
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    azurebricks · 100% · 181 feedback
    £23.71 incl. £2.26 postage 11.1p/piece About typical
  26. lego creator 40597 scary pirate island
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    portlandmk · 100% · 44 feedback
    £23.75 incl. £2.26 postage 11.1p/piece About typical
  27. LEGO CREATOR 40597 Scary Pirate Island 214pcs 8+ 2023 Complete Set Box
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    stajop_0 · 100% · 289 feedback
    £23.76 incl. £2.26 postage 11.1p/piece About typical
  28. NEW LEGO 40597 Pirate Scary Island Set VIP GWP creator Halloween - Sealed
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    macpherson1985 · 100% · 116 feedback
    £23.76 incl. £2.26 postage 11.1p/piece About typical
  29. LEGO Creator Scary Pirate Island 40597 8+ 214pcs Limited Edition Retired
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    rowil_2899 · 100% · 16 feedback
    £23.76 incl. £2.26 postage 11.1p/piece About typical
  30. LEGO 40597 Creator Pirate Island RETIRED
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    mio0221 · 100% · 67 feedback
    £23.76 incl. £2.26 postage 11.1p/piece About typical
  31. LEGO 40597 PIRATE ISLAND BRAND NEW & SEALED
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    richard-2nd · 99.2% · 2,314 feedback
    £23.76 incl. £2.26 postage 11.1p/piece About typical
  32. LEGO 40597 Scary Pirate Island - Brand New Boxed - Sealed
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    palekar · 100% · 1,586 feedback
    £23.76 incl. £2.26 postage 11.1p/piece About typical
  33. Lego Creator 8+: Scary Pirate Island (40597) Exclusive - Brand New & Sealed
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    deboramorto_8 · 100% · 161 feedback
    £23.76 incl. £2.26 postage 11.1p/piece About typical
  34. Lego Creator 40597 Scary Pirate Island New Boxed
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    pahun_2584 · 100% · 1,322 feedback
    £23.96 incl. £2.46 postage 11.2p/piece About typical
  35. SCARY PIRATE ISLAND new Lego set 40597 sealed box, CREATOR
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    lisas-lego · 100% · 918 feedback
    £24.11 incl. £2.62 postage 11.3p/piece About typical
  36. LEGO 40597 Creator Scary Pirate Island Set New & Sealed
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    bricklosophyandcompany · 100% · 64 feedback
    £24.12 incl. £2.62 postage 11.3p/piece About typical
  37. Lego GWP Scary Pirate Island (40597) Limited Edition - Brand New & Sealed
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    walltowallventure · 100% · 151 feedback
    £25.66 free postage 12.0p/piece 8% above typical
  38. Lego Creator: Scary Pirate Island 40597 - Brand New & Sealed Set
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    simsi-7393 · 100% · 88 feedback
    £26.88 incl. £2.26 postage 12.6p/piece 13% above typical
  39. Lego 40597 Scary Pirate Island Rare Quick Post
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    thoughtbubble2004 · 100% · 841 feedback
    £26.88 incl. £2.26 postage 12.6p/piece 13% above typical
  40. Lego Creator 8+: Scary Pirate Island (40597) Exclusive - Brand New & Sealed
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    leadhead35 · 100% · 1,272 feedback
    £27.24 incl. £2.62 postage 12.7p/piece 15% above typical
  41. Lego Creator 40597 Scary Pirate Island New With Original Packaging
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    bargainhuntingstore · 100% · 167 feedback
    £28.95 incl. £2.26 postage 13.5p/piece 22% above typical
  42. LEGO Creator Scary Pirate Island 40597 Brand New Sealed
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    brickraiders · 100% · 300 feedback
    £28.96 incl. £2.26 postage 13.5p/piece 22% above typical
  43. LEGO 40597 Scary Pirate Island Building & Pirates Add On ViP Pack Brand New
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    primolnauk · 99.2% · 626 feedback
    £31.91 incl. £2.62 postage 14.9p/piece 35% above typical
  44. Lego - Creator Scary Pirate Island 40597 - BNIB & Sealed
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    bits2022 · 99.4% · 409 feedback
    £33.11 incl. £2.26 postage 15.5p/piece 40% above typical
  45. LEGO 40597 Scary Pirate Island - NEW & SEALED
    UK New & sealed 📦 Box 📘 Instructions
    thomasthetrain78 · 100% · 3,099 feedback
    £34.52 incl. £2.62 postage 16.1p/piece 46% above typical

Only seeing UK listings. Compare all 5 countries →

Before you buy 40597

  • Check all 1 minifigure are included. Minifigures are the first thing sold off from used sets, and often the most valuable part.
  • “Complete” should mean all 214 pieces. Ask the seller whether they checked against the inventory or just think it's complete.
  • Sealed means factory seals intact. Ask for photos of the seals and box corners; box condition moves the price a lot on retired sets.
  • Check the seller's feedback. For a retired set, stick to sellers with 98%+ feedback and a history of selling LEGO.
  • Watch out for knock-offs. Brands like Lepin and Mould King copy popular sets. Look for the LEGO logo on the box and bricks.
  • Pay through eBay. eBay's Money Back Guarantee covers items that don't match the description, but only if you pay through eBay.

Questions

How much is LEGO 40597 Scary Pirate Island worth?

Based on current eBay UK Buy It Now listings, a new sealed set typically costs £23.71, including postage. These are asking prices, so a set can sell for less.

How many pieces are in LEGO 40597?

Scary Pirate Island has 214 pieces and 1 minifigure. It was released in 2023.

What is the price per piece of 40597?

At the typical sealed price of £23.71 it works out at 11.1p per piece.

More Creator sets from around 2023

All Creator →
LEGO 10272 Old Trafford - Manchester United
10272Old Trafford - Manchester United2020 · 3,898 pcsfrom £260
LEGO 31141 Main Street
31141Main Street2023 · 1,460 pcs · 6 figsfrom £85.98
LEGO 31120 Medieval Castle
31120Medieval Castle2021 · 1,426 pcs · 4 figsfrom £103
LEGO 31109 Pirate Ship
31109Pirate Ship2020 · 1,260 pcs · 4 figsfrom £64.75
LEGO 31132 Viking Ship and the Midgard Serpent
31132Viking Ship and the Midgard Serpent2022 · 1,191 pcs · 4 figsfrom £91.90
LEGO 31119 Ferris Wheel
31119Ferris Wheel2021 · 1,002 pcs · 5 figsfrom £34.16
LEGO 10271 Fiat 500
10271Fiat 5002020 · 960 pcsfrom £37.28
LEGO 77942 Fiat 500 - Bright Light Blue Version
77942Fiat 500 - Bright Light Blue Version2021 · 960 pcsfrom £88.17